![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Today, King Amusement Creative announced on YouTube a TV anime of Tokyo Babylon done by GoHands production to come in 2021. The trailer is embedded below in case you are the single TB fan who lived under an extraterrestrial rock during the previous week. The animation in the trailer looks beautiful and the character design appears to be close to what we saw in Clamp in Wonderland.
However, I admit having very mixed feelings.
On the one hand - I'm all over the moon, too, because who wouldn't LOVE getting a TB anime?!?
On the other hand, there are two things that keep me from being all exuberant now.
Firstly, CiWo's character design (and the one in the trailer linked above) doesn't click well with me. It's beautiful, clear-lined, fluent, and works well for the twins, but Seishiro... looks strange for me. I guess mostly because of the different glasses, but sheesh - that's your shallow writer for you; and you can be sure it won't keep me from watching!
The second thing is more serious, though. I've only been an active participant - creating fan works, participating in discussions, etc. - in four small fandoms (Galaxy Rangers, Emperor's Edge, Viewfinder, and TBX - if you are curious), and two of them died when new material was released after a long hiatus.
In one case, it was just the release of the source material as a DVD set, in the other, the book series was continued after what was a bitter-sweet but fitting conclusion and the fandoms just evaporated. People consumed the new material... and discussions died down, interactions dwindled, exchanges stopped... the mailing list of the DVD fandom trickled down to being mostly the "you have to renew your subscription"-mail once a year, and the book forum became a ghost town, not over night, but within weeks of the new volume.
The fandoms didn't survive the new material. At all. Viewfinder never had a real hiatus, just an awfully slow release cycle to begin with, and I wasn't that active in it to begin with, so it can't serve as a counterexample.
I can help but fear that something similar may happen to TBX - and that would be so devastating.
However, I admit having very mixed feelings.
On the one hand - I'm all over the moon, too, because who wouldn't LOVE getting a TB anime?!?
On the other hand, there are two things that keep me from being all exuberant now.
Firstly, CiWo's character design (and the one in the trailer linked above) doesn't click well with me. It's beautiful, clear-lined, fluent, and works well for the twins, but Seishiro... looks strange for me. I guess mostly because of the different glasses, but sheesh - that's your shallow writer for you; and you can be sure it won't keep me from watching!
The second thing is more serious, though. I've only been an active participant - creating fan works, participating in discussions, etc. - in four small fandoms (Galaxy Rangers, Emperor's Edge, Viewfinder, and TBX - if you are curious), and two of them died when new material was released after a long hiatus.
In one case, it was just the release of the source material as a DVD set, in the other, the book series was continued after what was a bitter-sweet but fitting conclusion and the fandoms just evaporated. People consumed the new material... and discussions died down, interactions dwindled, exchanges stopped... the mailing list of the DVD fandom trickled down to being mostly the "you have to renew your subscription"-mail once a year, and the book forum became a ghost town, not over night, but within weeks of the new volume.
The fandoms didn't survive the new material. At all. Viewfinder never had a real hiatus, just an awfully slow release cycle to begin with, and I wasn't that active in it to begin with, so it can't serve as a counterexample.
I can help but fear that something similar may happen to TBX - and that would be so devastating.
no subject
Date: 2020-10-25 18:49 (UTC)From:Okay, not to be cruel here but face it, TBX is kind of dead already? >_> My hope is that it'll bring ppl back.
no subject
Date: 2020-10-25 19:04 (UTC)From:no subject
Date: 2020-10-26 23:18 (UTC)From: (Anonymous)As far as the fandom dying off the only assurance one can possibly offer there is, the fandom has survived to one degree or another for 30 years (or nearly 20 if you're counting the English release of the manga). Those of us who have stuck around will probably keep sticking around. Cause no matter what happens with this show we will always have the manga - and that was what most of us were here for anyway.
Keep doing that heavy lifting in helping keep people engaged with that awesome fit of yours!
no subject
Date: 2020-10-27 08:11 (UTC)From:My former fandom was over 15 years old by the time the DVDs hit the market - and I was / am still writing long!fic in it, so it's not comforting (sadly), but regarding the manga - yes, absolutely. Hopefully, there'll be a rerelease of it - the paper it's printed on is suffering, too.
no subject
Date: 2020-10-27 22:50 (UTC)From: (Anonymous)I for one promise to continue pimping great fan works for this series (and this series itself), until the end of time! (especially tasty epic fanfics!)
no subject
Date: 2020-11-01 15:43 (UTC)From:no subject
Date: 2020-10-27 21:01 (UTC)From:no subject
Date: 2020-11-01 15:42 (UTC)From:I'm just worried, because my previous experiences with revivals (what type ever) weren't promising.