"Star Trek is the second oldest fandom in existence. [...] I honestly don't think you can bring a new idea to the fandom. We've seen it all before, really. [...] you'll need more than a gimick to keep our attention [...] If you want us to respect you [...]"
[source: http://community.livejournal.com/fanficrants/8227664.html]
I am fan enough to have spent a fortune on tapes to record the various series when they -finally- aired on German TV. And I freely admit that I loved TOS and some of the later installments (though not TNG, with few humoresque exceptions). But to start writing means to treat into new territory. You have to learn the symbolism, the characters, and you will make mistakes until you figure things out. Therefore, statements like the one quoted above made me never to touch anything remotely StarTrek fanwise with anything but a very long pole. It certainly kept me from ever writing it (ever since the '90s).
Whether that's been good or bad (for me or ST) we'll never know, but it certainly allows me now to grab the e-popcorn, lean back and watch the battle to unfold. To quote one of the fashion entertainers in the -admittedly abysmal- model shows on German TV:
"Drama, baby, drama!" [*eg*]
no subject
Date: 2009-05-19 18:22 (UTC)From:I had ideas for several fandoms back then, but German fandoms weren't really "online" yet and with English being my second language, I was conscious about posting in English. I certainly looked at the people active in those to determine where to risk putting my foot in. Esp. since it was likely that I would misunderstood even common comments in the beginning. School English helps with stories about kittens, it certainly leaves you in the lurch when it comes to slang & lolcats. ;)
These days, I consider the frequent "canon Trek Wars" as a form of entertainment, superior to the canon they are about. (And ST does have some of the sweetest villains. Romulans, Cardassians... ;)
Hi. :) Nice to meet you, too. I wanted to say "hello" when I subscribed to your journal here, but somehow it slipped my mind while resolving importing issues, payment issues, thesis issues... I'm sorry to have been accidentally rude. I subscribed mostly because I enjoyed some of your TBX fics, before I started writing X myself. (I stop reading fics when I write in a fandom to avoid influences.))